Andrew Gutman BTB Podcast

Andrew Gutman: From College Walk-On to the MAC Hermann Trophy, And Everything That Came After

Share this Post:

Welcome to BTB

We are a soccer mentorship platform for ambitious players and their families.

Learn More

Elsewhere:

the underdog's edge

Stories, lessons and perspective from inside soccer, every Tuesday.

Free every Tuesday.
Unsubscribe anytime.

Stay close to the game

LISTEN ON SPOTIFY | LISTEN ON APPLE | WATCH ON YOUTUBE

One of the things I’ve always respected about Andrew Gutman’s approach to his professional soccer career is how seriously he takes his preparation.

I’ve played alongside a lot of talented players throughout my career, but Andrew is one of the most meticulous guys I’ve been around when it comes to recovery, nutrition, and taking care of his body.

What I didn’t fully appreciate until sitting down with him was just how much adversity he experienced before we ever became teammates at Chicago Fire.

Andrew grew up in Chicago, played in the Chicago Fire Academy, spent four years at Indiana University, and eventually won the MAC Hermann Trophy as the best player in college soccer. He then signed with Celtic FC before building his professional soccer career in Major League Soccer.

But his journey was anything but straightforward.

In this episode of the BTB Podcast, we talked about his unlikely rise through college soccer, the challenges he faced after signing in Europe, the unpredictable business of professional sports, and the habits that have helped him sustain his career.

In this conversation, you’ll hear:

  • Why Andrew was one of the worst players on his academy team at 15 years old.
  • How a weekend visit to his brother at Indiana led to an opportunity that changed his career.
  • What happened when Celtic couldn’t secure his work permit and his dream move to Europe took an unexpected turn.
  • How an unexpected trade from Atlanta to Colorado changed his perspective on professional soccer.
  • Why gaining weight and changing his approach to recovery became important parts of staying healthy.

Watch or listen to the full conversation below.

LISTEN ON SPOTIFY | LISTEN ON APPLE | WATCH ON YOUTUBE

From one of the worst players to the best in college soccer

One of the most revealing moments of our conversation came when Andrew described his first year in the Chicago Fire Academy.

He joined at 15 years old and, by his own admission, was one of the least-developed players on the team. He barely got playing time, struggled with the speed of training, and remembered coming home embarrassed after difficult sessions.

He could have returned to his previous club, where he would’ve been one of the better players. Instead, he stayed.

By the time he was 16, his development had been remarkable.

That willingness to remain uncomfortable became a defining characteristic of his career.

When it came time for college, Andrew wasn’t a highly recruited prospect. In fact, he only ended up meeting Indiana’s coaching staff because his parents encouraged him to reach out while visiting his brother.

He was offered a place on the team with essentially enough financial assistance to cover his books.

Four years later, he won the MAC Hermann Trophy.

I love this story because it challenges how quickly we evaluate young players based on their current ability, playing time, or recruiting interest.

Andrew’s future wasn’t determined by where he stood at 15. He was willing to keep developing, even when everyone around him appeared to be further ahead.

When signing for Celtic didn’t go according to plan

You would think winning the MAC Hermann Trophy and signing with Celtic would be the moment everything started falling into place.

For Andrew, it was almost the opposite.

After arriving in Scotland, he learned that he wouldn’t receive the work permit needed to play for Celtic. Instead of competing for one of Europe’s most historic clubs, he suddenly found himself heading on loan to Charlotte Independence in the USL.

He admitted how frustrating the situation was. But rather than allowing that disappointment to affect his preparation, he continued approaching every training session and game as seriously as possible.

Eventually, he earned another opportunity with Celtic’s first team during preseason. The manager told him he wanted to keep him around, only for the work permit situation to prevent it once again.

Andrew eventually found himself at FC Cincinnati, where something interesting happened.

Despite playing for a struggling team, he credits that experience with helping save his career.

Why?

Because he finally had the opportunity to play consistently, make mistakes, receive criticism, and improve.

I thought this was an important reminder that development isn’t always about being associated with the biggest clubs or the most prestigious environments.

Sometimes the opportunity to actually play, struggle, and learn is exactly what a young player needs.

LISTEN ON SPOTIFY | LISTEN ON APPLE | WATCH ON YOUTUBE

What Andrew Gutman’s MLS career taught him about the business of soccer

Another part of Andrew’s story that stood out was how quickly his circumstances could change.

During his time with Atlanta United, he was playing regularly, enjoying the city, and felt like he’d found somewhere he could potentially spend the rest of his career.

Then, one morning, while driving to breakfast with his wife and brother, he received a phone call from his agent.

He’d been traded to the Colorado Rapids.

Just like that, everything changed.

Andrew described the frustration of leaving a place where he’d become comfortable, but he also recognized that he couldn’t control the decision. What he could control was how he approached his next opportunity.

Having experienced the business side of professional soccer myself, I know how challenging these situations can be.

As players, we invest so much into our clubs, teammates, and communities. But professional soccer is also a business, and your circumstances can change regardless of how well you’re performing.

Andrew’s earlier experiences had prepared him to handle that uncertainty.

The habits that helped him sustain his career

Having shared a locker room with Andrew, I knew how disciplined he was with his nutrition, recovery, and preparation.

But I was particularly interested in hearing how his approach evolved after experiencing injuries throughout his career.

One of his biggest realizations involved his body weight.

For years, he’d believed being lighter would help him run more and perform better. Eventually, he began questioning whether that approach was actually helping him stay healthy.

After the 2024 season, he intentionally gained approximately six or seven pounds and found that the additional weight helped him feel stronger and recover more effectively between games.

What stood out to me wasn’t necessarily the change in weight itself, but his willingness to question something he’d believed for years.

Even as a professional, Andrew was still learning what worked best for his body.

And I think that’s an important lesson for young players. Taking your development seriously doesn’t mean blindly following the same routines forever. It means paying attention, learning, and making adjustments as you gain experience.

LISTEN ON SPOTIFY | LISTEN ON APPLE | WATCH ON YOUTUBE

Find something that separates you

Near the end of our conversation, I asked Andrew what advice he’d give his younger self.

His answer was simple: identify one quality in your game that can separate you from other players, and spend additional time developing it.

For Andrew, that meant becoming more effective as an attacking fullback through crossing, overlapping runs, and delivering dangerous passes.

He wished he’d started deliberately developing those qualities at 15 rather than waiting until his early twenties.

I thought this was excellent advice.

Every young player wants to improve, but improvement becomes much more intentional when you understand your position, identify what makes you valuable, and dedicate time to developing those specific qualities.

It’s something I wish more young players thought about when deciding how to spend their individual training time. For players looking to take more ownership of that process, we’ve put together a collection of free player development resources at BTB.

What I’ll remember from this conversation

The thing that stays with me from Andrew’s story isn’t necessarily winning the MAC Hermann Trophy, signing with Celtic, or establishing himself in MLS.

It’s how often things didn’t go according to plan.

He struggled in the academy, arrived at college without much recognition, experienced setbacks in Europe, and dealt with trades and injuries throughout his professional career.

Yet those experiences became an important part of who he developed into.

When I asked what he’d do differently if he could go back to being 15 years old, Andrew said he’d put himself in uncomfortable situations all over again.

I think that’s a powerful perspective for any young player who feels behind in their development.

Where you stand today doesn’t necessarily determine where you’ll end up. What matters is how you respond to the opportunities and challenges in front of you.

And Andrew’s story is a great example of that.

Watch or listen to the full episode above. And if you know a young player who’s struggling with playing time, confidence, or feeling behind in their development, send them this conversation.

For more lessons from inside the game, subscribe to The Underdog’s Edge, BTB’s weekly newsletter for players and parents.

LISTEN ON SPOTIFY | LISTEN ON APPLE | WATCH ON YOUTUBE

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Welcome to BTB

We are a soccer mentorship platform for ambitious players and their families.

Learn More

Elsewhere:

The Locker Room

Path 2 Pro

The Newsletter

the underdog's edge

Stories, lessons and perspective from inside soccer, every Tuesday.

Free every Tuesday.
Unsubscribe anytime.

Stay close to the game

Further Reading / Further Reading / Further Reading / Further Reading /

Looking for something specific? Select a popular category or enter your search query below.

on the blog